1. Put the requirements in writing
Your subcontract (or your client's contract with you) usually sets the coverage types and minimum limits, and whether you must be named as additional insured. Keep a short summary per trade so the person reviewing certificates has something to compare against.
2. Collect before work starts
Make the certificate part of onboarding, alongside the W-9 and the signed subcontract. Ask the sub to have their agent send it directly; agents issue certificates and can include the right certificate holder and endorsements.
3. Review each certificate
Check the named insured, coverage lines, limits, policy dates and the additional insured and waiver boxes. The details are in what to check on a COI. Remember that a box checked on a certificate points to an endorsement; many contracts ask for the endorsement itself.
4. Track expirations
Record the expiration date of each line you require. The free spreadsheet template covers this, and expiration reminders explains when to follow up.
5. Decide what happens on a lapse
Agree internally (and in the subcontract) what happens when a certificate expires: hold payment, pause site access, or escalate. Then make sure someone hears about the lapse on the day.
Where COI Nudge fits
COI Nudge covers step 4 and the follow-up in step 5: it tracks each expiration date and emails before and after. It does not read certificates, check limits or give insurance advice, so steps 1 to 3 stay with your team. Try 3 vendors free.